Showing posts with label Shakespeare. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Shakespeare. Show all posts

Saturday, April 26, 2014


‘As You Like It’ is a big, beautiful blast at Lenox

                David Begelman
 
Theater Critic

If you’ve ever harbored any reservations about the capability of Shakespeare & Company, your doubts should be dispelled on the spot while savoring its current production of Shakespeare’s “As You Like It.” This is as stellar a staging of a Shakespeare play you’re likely to see in many a moon.

It’s not the only comedy of the bard in which a female character hides her true identity in male garb (“Merchant of Venice” and “Twelfth Night” contain such conceits), nor the only one in which a woman seeks refuge in a forest (“Midsummer Night’s Dream” includes this scenario.) But for a heroine bestowed with a mother load of ingenuity and personal resources, Rosalind is up there with the best of them. Exile in the Forest of Arden is pretty much a cakewalk for her.

The actress who portrays her in this production, Merritt Janson, is such a bundle of talent, her every word, gesture—and even her gymnastic sallies—are delightful, springing as they do from an obvious wellspring of ability topped with a fetching smile.

Janson is surrounded by a team of performers whose portrayals only enhance the attractiveness of this production. Although many different styles of performance grace the latter, Director Tony Simotes has calibrated them so deftly, there’s not a downbeat or discordant note anywhere in the effort.

The comic relief in this staging simply has to be seen in order to be appreciated. Humorous touches, delivered with on-cue precision by several cast members entrusted with the lion’s share of creating jollity, need to be mentioned. They are: Jonathan Epstein in a wily and hilarious rendition of Touchstone, Malcolm Ingram as the faithful, but doddering retainer Adam, who always manages to convey the impression he is on the brink of death, Kevin O’Donnell as the puffed-up Charles the Wrestler, Dana Harrison as the flighty Phebe, and Jennie M. Jadow as the lusty Audrey.

In less comedic characterizations, Tony Roach was full of youthful vigor and romantic longing as Orlando; Johnny Lee Davenport turned in sturdy portrayals as the competing potentates, Duke Frederick and Duke Senior, while Wolfe Coleman crafted a commendable performance as Orlando’s nasty brother, Oliver.

Kelly Curran was especially riveting as Rosalind’s close friend, Celia, and the scenes between her and Janson were in the opinion of this reviewer among the highlights of the show.

Director Simotes chose to adapt a Parisian 1920 ambience for the setting of the play, and if you failed to consult the playbill, you’d be a bit perplexed why the sound of the “La Marseillaise” was being piped in, or military types on stage were prancing around in French legionnaire uniforms. Maybe Simotes attached more importance to this than necessary; the setting and costumes could have been Elizabethan, Jacobean or Edwardian without any appreciable sacrifice to the overall quality of this production.

Serious theatergoers shouldn’t forfeit the opportunity to catch this impressive show. Bravo!

“As You Like It” runs through September 4 at the Founders’ Theatre, Shakespeare & Company, 70 Kemble Street, Lenox, Mass. Performances are Wednesday, Friday and Saturday 7:30 p.m., Sunday matinees 2 p.m. Tickets are $10-$85 and may be purchased by calling the box office at 413-637-3353 or online at www.shakespeare.org.   

 

 

 

 

Friday, April 25, 2014


 

“Twelfth Night” opens at The Schoolhouse Theater

By David Begelman

Theater Critic

Shakespeare’s “Twelfth Night,” like “Merchant of Venice” is one of those festive comedies with a dark underbelly. The two plays push the limits of comedy by addressing concerns that have a deeper social impact on audiences.

They also share other characteristics, like women in male roles and overkill when it comes to villains getting their just desserts. In “The Merchant of Venice,” Shylock’s wealth is confiscated, and he’s forced to convert to Christianity. In “Twelfth Night,” for being uptight and puritanical, Malvolio is not only humiliated to the max, he’s consigned to a dark room for a spell. It’s the treatment usually reserved for the mentally ill in the seventeenth century.

“Twelfth Night,” like “Midsummer Night’s Dream,” celebrates another Shakespearean spin on love. The scene is set in Ilyria, a mythical kingdom under the sway of two households, those of Orsino and Olivia. The former, a reflective and love-smitten Duke, opens the comedy with the line, “If music be the food of love, play on.” He’s stuck on Olivia, and in the manner of royal prerogative, arranges for someone else to do his pleading for him.

This turns out to be the heroine of the comedy, Viola. She, like Prospero and Miranda in “The Tempest,” has survived a shipwreck. Her entrée into Orsino’s court is by dint of disguising herself as a man, and endearing herself to the Duke who recruits her to do his wooing.

Viola finds herself in the impossible situation of loving Orsino, who thinks she’s a man, as does Olivia, who promptly falls in love with her. At the end of the play, the truth is revealed, and love finds a way of righting itself. Viola and Orsino are happily matched, while Olivia makes do with Viola’s twin brother, Sebastian. He’s also survived the shipwreck, and turns up in the nick of time to become a reasonable facsimile of his sister in order to enrapture Olivia.

Since Elizabethan stage performers were all men, the actor who debuted in the role of Viola in 1602 was a man in a female role masquerading as a man. Sex-role confusions are a familiar Shakespearean conceit, employed in plays like “As You Like It” that are not dark comedies.

The performance of “Twelfth Night” at The Schoolhouse Theater borders on a ham-fisted approach to the comedy. Gone is any semblance of an ethereal atmosphere of Illyria, in favor of a more direct and less nuanced treatment by director Penny Cherns. There is altogether too much shouting (a by now familiar pattern in underscoring emotional emphasis in American, in contrast to British, Shakespearean productions).

Actors doubled in the roles of Curio/Sir Andrew Aguecheek (Ash Law Edwards), Valentine/Sebastian/Fabian (Jack Berenholtz), Captain/Feste/Officer (Jason Hart), Sir Toby Belch/Priest (Simon MacLean) and Malvolio/Antonio (Neal Mayer). The effect was for performers to exaggerate the qualities of their roles, in order to distinguish them for the audience. But the result in some cases approximated caricature, rather than nuanced interpretation.

“Twelfth Night” runs through June 10 at The Schoolhouse Theater, 3 Owens Road, Croton Falls, NY. Performances on Thursday, Friday and Saturday are 8 p.m., Sunday at 4 p.m. Tickets are $33 on Thursday and Friday and $35 on Saturday and Sunday, and may be purchased by calling the box office at 914-277-8477 or contacting www.schoolhousetheater.org.

 

 

The Winter’s Tale falters at Lenox

 David Begelman , Theater Critic

Shakespeare’s “The Winter’s Tale,” leaning on a plot in Robert Greene’s “Pandosto: The Triumph of Time,” was probably authored in 1611. It was among a late cycle of dramas which, like “Pericles,” “Cymbeline,” and “The Tempest” are called “romances.”  A mixture of tragic and comic elements, they were inspired by stories originating in ancient Greece that tell of wanderers, heroes who escape disaster, shepherds frolicking about the countryside, and star-crossed lovers who are separated before finally being united.

The play’s action is driven by a delusion of Leontes, King of Sicilia, that his wife, Hermione, has been having an affair with his long-time friend, Polixenes, king of Bohemia. The latter has been a visitor at court, and Leontes is convinced his queen is pregnant with his friend’s child.

Things go from bad to worse. Leontes tries to have Polixenes poisoned, puts Hermione on trial for treason, banishes her newborn babe to the hinterlands, and receives news that his young son Maximilius has died. Apollo sends the monarch glum tidings from the Delphic oracle that he has screwed up royally. But it’s the death of his son and collapse of his wife in court that takes the wind out of his paranoia, resulting in his abject contrition.

In director Kevin G. Coleman’s present staging of the play, the gloomy court of Sicilia is bedecked in black, white, and reddish sets and costumes, while walk-on performers strike stationary poses on stage. They also have problems aplenty speaking the King’s English. Only Jonathan Epstein as Leontes seemed suffused with believable emotion after the onset of a psychosis that erupts all too complacently for “an infection of my brains.”

The production makes a spirited effort to enliven things in the kingdom of Polixenes (Johnny Lee Davenport). The switch to an upbeat atmosphere in this realm is clear in Shakespeare’s play. Bohemia abounds in peasants, shepherds, and all around merriment. Except in this production, the jollity escalates into a fracas in which peasants have at each other as if they were in a street rumble.

Comic relief comes in the form of Autolycus (Jason Asprey), a self-professed “snapper-up of unconsidered trifles”—in short, a thief. He pilfers money from a wandering clown who turns out to be the son of the Old Shepherd (Malcolm Ingram). The latter has reared Perdita (Kelly Galvin) from infancy. She is in reality Leontes’ abandoned babe. Asprey lightened things up considerably, although by being on the manicky side, there was a loss of some of his dialogue

Hermione (Elizabeth Aspenlieder) usually is played as a woman who, although victimized by her husband’s jealous rage, still retains her dignity—even when on trial for her life. Aspenlieder’s interpretation of the role emphasized more the character’s crumbling under pressure, a quite different spin. Improbably, she sported a funky blond Shirley Temple wig that struck a frivolous note for a luckless queen.

Current productions at Shakespeare and Company use audience aisles to some advantage, although the interplays with the audience get to be on the slapstick side.

“The Winter’s Tale” continues through September 5 at the Founders’ Theatre, Shakespeare and Company, 70 Kemble St., Lenox, Mass. Performances are Tuesdays through Saturdays at 7:30 p.m. and Sundays at 2 p.m. Tickets are $14-$85, and can be purchased by calling the box office at 413-637-3353, or contacting www.shakespeare.org, 

 

 

      

 

    

 

Faces of Infidelity: Othello and The Ladies Man at Shakespeare & Company

David Begelman

With a sidelong glance at the current political scene, 2008 must be the year of the farce. Is that the reason so many of them are being staged around the tri-state area? Westport Country Playhouse has mounted Scramble!, A Flea in Her Ear is being staged in Williamstown, and The Ladies Man has opened at the Founders Theatre in Lenox, Massachusetts. One way or another, the influence of Georges Feydeau is discernable in all three productions.

Many among us love farce. You were more than likely as not to see this reviewer hitting the floor in paroxysms of laughter when watching Shakespeare & Company’s rendition of The Ladies Man, freely adapted from Feydeau’s Tailleur pour Dames. The fit drew little more than sneers from sourpusses on either side of him in the audience as though, like Pooh-Bah—the Lord High Everything Else in the Mikado— they were born that way.

As part of what Shakespeare & Company calls its first brunch matinee event of the 2008 season, the theater has dished up a hilarious version of the Feydeau farce. All of the eight performers in its cast have the timing and precision of just what it takes to roll with the necessary ingredients: in and out of slamming doors, ill-timed assignations, faux German or French accents (sounding in the case of Dave Demke as Etienne, house valet, like John Cleese’s fawning French waiter in The Meaning of Life), accomplished gyrations in compromised physical positions, and the complexities and confusions of sexual scenarios gone haywire. It is a madcap romp in La Belle Epoch France.

There is little in Feydeau’s confection that compares to Othello, Shakespeare’s majestic treatment of a military commander who becomes a tortured soul. Yet the French farce is, in a curious way, the flip side of the towering tragedy. Both plays deal with  themes of imagined infidelity, albeit in ways that are worlds apart. The two are also double-billed on the same day at the Founders’ Theater in Lenox Massachusetts, as if one of them was intended to be relief from the other.

The two plays at Lenox also share several of the same performers, Shakespeare & Company’s ingenious way of underscoring the range of abilities in its seasoned actors. Jonathan Croy doubles as the beleaguered Dr. Hercule Molineaux in the Feydeau farce, and Lodovico in Othello; Walton Wilson enacts a stuffy, Bismarckean officer and husband in the farce, and an outraged Brabantio, father of Desdemona, in the tragedy; Michael F. Toomey plays the lisping and hounded Bassinet in the farce, and Montano in Shakespeare’s play, while the multi-tasker Elizabeth Aspenlieder (she’s the publicity director for the company), plays a wife who is determined to cuckhold her Prussian husband in an acrobatic play for Dr. Molineaux that is, choreographically speaking, a tour de force. She’s also Bianca, mistress of the traduced Michael Cassio in Othello.     

The Shakespearean tragedy, one of the playwright’s finest, is a tightly constructed drama about a military commander in the Venetian army whose aide contrives to destroy him through innuendo about the infidelity of his adoring wife, Desdemona. The worm in the equation is Iago, arguably the most perfidious villain in all of dramatic literature. “Honest Iago” is the general’s spin on his treacherous aide, played by Michael Hammond as a silver-haired patrician type. The interpretation is an unusual, albeit plausible one, and a cut apart from the gruff, bawdy, NCO-type of villain portrayed by, for example, Frank Finlay or Bob Hoskins.

Mr. Hammond’s interpretation of the role leans heavily on the humorous side of the villain, less on the terrifyingly dark side of his “malignity without motive” lurking under all other aspects of his persona. Although Mr. Hammond’s performance was distinctive, it never quite raised the hair on the back of one’s neck, as this villain was meant to do.

The character of Othello may be the most daunting challenge for an actor in all of dramatic literature. It certainly was for the likes of actors from Salvini to Olivier. Not all characterizations were successful because of the demanding nature of the role, and performers went down like bowling pins in the face of the challenge. David Garrick, the outstanding naturalistic actor of the eighteenth century, bombed in the role. Othello invariably exacts a price from any lead not up to the subtle and not so subtle transitions of emotional intensity, rage, and contrition.

John Douglas Thompson has a head start on the portrayal of Shakespeare’s tragic hero. He is equipped physically for the role, and his presence on stage is always commanding. Director Tony Simotes’ approach to Act III, Scene III, in which Iago’s venomous insinuations start to unravel his general, was wisely moderated, and Othello’s fury was unleashed with intensity only subsequently in scenes with Desdemona. Mr. Thompson’s choice of an African dialect, while emphasizing a perception of Othello as “the other” in a Venetian state that must have represented its share of culture shock for a black foreigner, nonetheless became a clipped, somewhat awkward overlay atop the beauty of the verse. Nonetheless, Mr. Thompson had moments on stage that compared favorably to the best performances of the past. This is no mean accomplishment in a role the gods have deemed impossibly difficult.

Other performers acquitted their roles well, if not memorably. Yoshi Tanokura’s four-pillar set design was impressive, while Les Dickert’s amber lighting bathed performers in a perfect ambience for ongoing action.

Overall, a most enjoyable day in the theater—if you aim to laugh and cry within a short span of hours.

The Ladies Man opened at Shakespeare & Company at 70 Kemble Street in Lenox, MA on May 23, 2008. Othello opened on July 18. Both shows continue to August 31, 2008. Evening performances are at 8:00 PM, matinees at 3:00 PM. Tickets range from $15 to $60, and may be purchased by calling (413)-637-3353 or online at www.shakespeare.org

      

 

        

     

“The Tempest” a mixed blessing at Shakespeare & Company

 David Begelman

Theater Critic

The ending lines of Shakespeare’s last play form the couplet “If you from crimes would pardon’d be, Let your indulgence set me free.” Well, forgiveness may extend to many things, but not to deleting those words (or the epilogue preceding them). They celebrate the bard’s poignant farewell to the theater.

But that’s just what director Tony Simotes does in the current production of “The Tempest” in Lenox. There are several other questionable directorial choices in the show, along with positive and innovative touches. All things considered, the beauty of the play and its poetic imagery shine through an occasional misdirected attempt to do justice to one of the glories of dramatic literature.

Simotes has by now has established himself as a master of the comic conceit. His technique is more at home in plays like “As You Like It” or farces than it might be in dark comedies like “Twelfth Night” or in Shakespeare’s later romantic comedies like “The Tempest.” In these plays, an ethereal or magical atmosphere should pervade a vehicle. This can be jarred by the antics of performers who exaggerate how funny they can be or who play tastelessly to the audience.

In the current updated production, the role of Prospero, renamed Prospera, is taken by an actress (Olympia Dukakis). This is hardly news. In the 2010 film adaptation of the same play, the British actress Helen Mirren was cast in the role. Female actors in leading male roles was innovated as early as Sarah Bernhardt’s “Hamlet.” In Shakespeare’s time all female roles were undertaken by males. No point in declaring it’s time to level the playing field. This has been happening all along. The character of Ariel, the sprite who does Prospero’s bidding, is a male role. But it is played as often by women (Kristin Wold in this production).

Dukakis’s interpretation of Prospera seemed to lack gravitas. At times she appeared to be less in command of her “bare island” despite her magical powers. The actress sometimes radiated more agitation than imperial control of events swirling around her. And she tended to become snippy, rather than calm things down in a more serene way. What’s the point of being a powerful magician holding sway over an island if every little setback has you riled up?

Merritt Janson as Miranda, Prospera’s daughter, supplies a richer interpretation of her role. The part is usually taken by an actress who projects simplicity, obedience, and innocence. Janson has Miranda much more gutsy about the “brave new world that hath such people in‘t.” When it comes to Ferdinand (Ryan Winkles), a newcomer to her island, her appetite for him includes some secret hand-holding and schmoozing behind the back of her ever vigilant mother. It’s a rebellion waiting to happen.

Other commendable interpretations were of Gonzalo (Apollo Dukakis), Stephano (Jonathan Epstein) and Caliban (Rocco Sisto). The spirits of Juno (Stephanie Hedges), Iris (Casey McShain), Ceres (Jennifer Young) and Spirit (Monica Giordano) who “Are melted into air” could do without the garish costumes designed by Deborah Brothers. These are imaginary goddesses, not paraders at Mardi Gras in Rio.

“The Tempest” runs through August 19 at the Tina Packer Playhouse, Shakespeare & Company, 70 Kemble Street, Lenox, MA 01240. Performances are  Tuesdays through Sundays at varying 2 p.m. and 7:30 p.m. schedules. Tickets are $15 to $95 and may be purchased online at www.shakespeare.org or by calling the Box Office at (413)-637-3353.

 

 

Psychoanalysis and Shakespeare: Cruising the Canon
 
David Begelman 

Psychoanalytic approaches to Shakespeare’s plays seem to me to represent misdirections and diversions from a proper assessment of the canon. Psychoanalytic interpretations of the motives of, say, Hamlet and Iago, may actually fail to do what they purport to do: explain the behavior of a central character in a play. On one interpretation, Hamlet procrastinates avenging his father’s death because his unconscious Oedipal fantasies would surface uncomfortably close to consciousness were he to murder his uncle outright; Iago’s hatefulness supposedly camouflages his homosexual desire for Othello or Cassio or both. That a generation of scholars could take these lucubrations seriously is the thing to be explained, not two of the most skillfully drawn personalities in all of literature.

Latent or unconscious homosexuality, as this is held to motivate the villain in Othello, seems to have exhausted its panoramic grip on American letters, not to mention the preoccupations of academics, notably professors of literature and philosophy.  Many of them in the past fastened onto it as a protean explanatory rubric. Perhaps one reason for its diminished role is the recent drift toward abandoning outdated ideas about the Other, including persons who maintain diverse life styles. Accordingly, repressed homosexuality in literature and the theater seems to have run its morbid course up to a point in time when everyone stopped being anxious about the possibility that the alleged condition was his or hers.  

American plays in which homosexuality is an ingredient theme, like Tennessee Williams’ Cat On A Hot Tin Roof, are often those in which the motive  is not repressed, but suppressed, affording little opportunity for the psychoanalytically inspired to do their thing. Big Daddy Pollitt, in the powerful second act of William’s play, forces his son Brick to face the erotic, and not especially unconscious, desire for his dead sports pal. Brick returns the lesson in truth-telling by informing Big Daddy he is dying from colon cancer. The father, furious that his condition has been kept from him, exits shouting that everyone—except his tortured son—is a liar. The “odor of mendacity” on Big Daddy’s plantation is relieved only by revelations that for father and son have been too searing to face prior to their explosive confrontation.   

Of course, perhaps a case might be made for psychoanalysis “explaining” Shakespearean characters were we to harbor some unusual sense of the term “explanation” for what psychoanalysts do with fictional characters. Freud likewise fancied he explained real individuals like Leonardo da Vinci and Michelangelo in his 1910 and 1914 monographs. Yet it only stands to reason that a theorist who can boldly declare, as he did in Totem and Taboo, that Moses was an Egyptian, deserves more in the way of skeptical reception.

Psychohistorians, following Freud, tend to put the cart before the horse. We cannot use psychology to recreate history before deferring to historians as fact finders. Psychology of whatever persuasion can only elaborate on established history. In addition, in Totem and Taboo Freud postulated that real life Oedipal dramas of wishing to kill the father and sexually possess the mother are actually throwbacks to a very real past, and were inherited from the experiences of our primordial ancestors. Such a formulation incorporates a discredited theory of genetic transmission, Lamarckianism, allowing for the inheritance of acquired characteristics. It rose to prominence in Soviet Russia, where Stalin’s handpicked agronomist, Trofim Lysenko, put forth a theory on a similar wave-length. Not all Soviet howlers were in the purely political arena.

On April 21, 1896, when Freud presented the first of his three “Seduction Theory” papers to the Viennese Medical Society, Richard Von Krafft-Ebing who chaired the meeting was moved to observe that the theory “sounds like a scientific fairy-tale.” The comment has been spun by psychoanalysts as the voice of a medical sensibility unprepared for a pioneer well in advance of his time. Freud himself characterized the reaction to his paper as “an icy reception from the asses.”  When he abandoned the theory mere months after announcing it, later retractions by psychoanalysts of their attitude to the dismissive judgment of Krafft-Ebing and his colleagues were nowhere in sight in the turgid prose of Freud’s insular circle. 

The Welsh scholar, Peter Swales, has demonstrated that some of the patients in Freud’s caseload were none other than himself disguised as paying customers, so that the honesty of the founder of psychoanalysis also comes under a cloud. For those of you who fall asleep at lectures, but can be roused to alertness when a National Enquirer-type tidbit is offered for consideration, should know that Dr. and Mrs. Sigmund Freud on vacation signed in at a European hotel and shared the same room. Except the woman was not Marthe Freud, the doctor’s wife, but Minna Bernays, his sister-in-law. So much for bourgeois physicians of flawless integrity. Of course, ad hominem arguments are no substitute for dispassionate criticism of theory, even if from time to time they are more fun. 

For what it’s worth, my hunch is that these so-called explanations have a moral, as well as a scientific thrust. To hold that the artistic products of the two great Renaissance painters can be explained by positing unresolved Oedipal feelings seems to be a backhanded way of demoting artistic achievement down to a nasty level of shared instincts. For me, the theory degrades creative achievement by consigning it to the ranks of mundane processes. To narrow the distance between me and Michelangelo would appear on the moral plane to demote him or elevate me. Were psychoanalysts to protest that all their theory seeks to do is to scientifically explain, not demote, creative genius, my response would be: “That may be the scientific aim of the formulation; but what is its moral aim?”

Psychoanalytic theory and its offshoot, psychoanalytic psychotherapy, are currently in disrepute as viable avenues of explanation and treatment. In my business, the treatment of troubled persons, psychoanalysis is largely an anachronism. I say “largely” here because patients do sometimes improve in this kind of psychotherapy. But they also improve in alternative forms of therapy, with a significant contribution of what we in the trade call “non-specific factors.” Suggestibility is a relevant component here, although behavior change in treatment is invariably attributed to its effect, as if the logical fallacy of post hoc ergo propter hoc were too much of a temptation for the enchanted to avoid.

The business of evaluating the effectiveness of psychotherapy is a tremendously complicated task for researchers. Effectiveness has to be the statistically significant advantage of any treatment approach over the advantage of receiving no treatment at all. Several studies, although not all, report dismal findings in this regard. The prestigious New York Psychoanalytic Institute many years ago undertook a study on the effectiveness of psychoanalysis. The results were so embarrassing to the profession, authorities at the Institute immediately suppressed the data. Evidently, for their ranks the truth not make you free.  

Ironically, the principal impetus for contemporary disenchantment with the house that Freud built comes from humanities scholars, many of whom who were once its staunchest supporters. I refer here to the commentary of philosophers like Adolph Grünbaum, Frank Cioffi, and Colin McGuinn, and others like Frederick Crews, Peter Swales, Max Scharnberg, Malcolm Macmillan, Allan Esterson, Stanley Fish, Hans J. Eysenck, Robyn Dawes, Frank J. Sulloway, Sebastian Timpanaro, Rosemarie Sand, and others too numerous to mention. Their disenchantment mirrors the nearly universal although less publicized disdain for psychoanalysis in the austere corridors of experimental psychology. Sir Peter Medawar, a Nobel Prize winner in Medicine, characterized Freud’s theory as a “stupendous confidence trick.” I cannot emphasize too strongly the power of this recent commentary. It is impressive and far reaching, and not the idle chatter of a few jaded souls.

One more point before we take up the plays. There seems to be a contemporary bias for “getting to the bottom” of a psychological problem, a trend that has been an unfortunate aftermath of psychoanalytic theorizing. When overemphasized—as it is these days—one can sense the overreach of a strictly motivational psychology. The charm of Freud’s theory in my opinion hinges on the belief that for every pattern of overt behavior there has to be a tacit narrative making it coherent in some scripted or literary way. This is probably why the theory has had such an appeal for humanities scholars. They are only too willing to popularize formulations that create subterranean texts with a motive structure all their own, differing from the features of overt behavior. It is as if at every step the ordinary reasons and motives for our behavior had to be deconstructed on pain of being regarded as superficial. The tacit literary script is seen as explaining the manifest one.

Allow me to refer you to one aftermath of this kind of thinking. I see a number of patients who have diagnosable panic disorder. The condition is characterized by unpredictable anxiety episodes and can incapacitate the patient, sometimes to the point of being housebound. The retreat maneuver is called agoraphobia, which is not as its Greek etymology would suggest, a fear of open spaces, but a fear of an anxiety attack in those places in which the episode previously occurred. Favorite sites for first occurrences are expressways, shopping centers, and restaurants. Housebound patients have agoraphobia in spades: they can have, or imagine they can have, an attack any place outside the home site to which they have unfortunately retreated. There are other forms of anxiety, but panic disorder is an unusually debilitating form of the condition. It can be treated with medication (usually a regimen of a selective serotonin reuptake inhibiter like Prozac or Zoloft, a tricyclic antidepressant like Imipramine, or anxiolytics like Xanax, and a cognitive-behavioral therapeutic approach involving desensitization strategies or flooding paradigms). Sometimes one or another of these modalities will do the trick. Panic disorder is democratic, while it affects more women than men, its sex-linked aspect is not as strident as it is for eating disorders (female), stuttering (male), self-mutilation (females), or Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (male). Its sometime victims have been the actor Phillip Bosco, the singer Carly Simon, the great operatic tenor Franco Corelli, and Sir Laurence Olivier.

The hitch is that there is a significant percentage of patients who refuse medication, not because they are enamored of wholistic health or natural rather than synthetically manufactured compounds, but because they “want to get to the bottom of the problem.” By this they mean they want to explore to the underlying psychodynamics of their condition, rather than rely on synthetic palliatives like medication. Note: medication is only a band-aid in their minds, whereas something akin to an underlying system of repressed impulses or conflicts, the unconscious narrative, is the real culprit. I sometimes remind them that patients with panic disorder react catastrophically to injections of Sodium Lactate, whereas the procedure has no effect on anxiety-free controls. In addition, there is a high concordance rate in identical twins for the disorder, and a familial risk. Doesn’t that suggest that the problem may lie in processes wholly outside the arena of unconscious motives? By the way, the fact that the root cause of panic disorder may be in the physiological realm does not preclude versions of cognitive therapies aimed at altering thinking about the condition. After all, changed thinking about a condition also has a physical representation in the nervous system. What won’t work is psychobabble about unconscious motives—for good reason. Panic disorder isn’t motivated; it just happens to people. The generalization remains true even for those episodes of the condition that are triggered by stress-related factors.

Hamlet’s World

I should like to quote at length a passage from Ernest Jones’ Hamlet and Oedipus to illustrate the kind of formulation of which I speak: 

Hamlet’s attitude towards his uncle-father is far more complex than is commonly supposed. He of course detests him, but it is the jealous detestation of one evil-doer toward his successful fellow…for the more vigorously he denounces his uncle the more powerfully does he stimulate to activity his own unconscious and “repressed” impulses…His own “evil” prevents him from completely denouncing his uncle’s, and in continuing to “repress” the former he must strive to ignore, to condone, and if possible even to forget the latter…In reality his uncle incorporates the deepest and most buried part of his own personality, so that he cannot kill him without also killing himself…Only when he has made the final sacrifice and brought himself to the door of death is he free to fulfill his duty, to avenge his father, and to slay his other self—his uncle  (Jones,  1949, p. 100).

There are several peculiarities in this short exposition of one influential psychoanalyst’s approach to the play. First, I cannot fathom why Jones says that Hamlet’s “own ‘evil’” prevents him from denouncing his uncle, or in “repressing” instincts he has to ignore, condone, or even forget his uncle’s evil deed. Hamlet denounces his uncle at every turn in the play, and he is hardly given to either ignoring, condoning, or forgetting the idea his uncle murdered his father at any point beyond the initial scene when he encounters the ghost for the first time. Quite the reverse. But if the so-called Oedipal conflict were the operative subtext of Hamlet’s character, would not Jones’ formulation lead to the expectation that Hamlet would indeed either condone or forget what his father’s ghost had revealed to him on the battlements of Elsinore Castle?

 To illustrate the suspiciously comprehensive texture of psychoanalytic theorizing, suppose I were to author a play about a prince who learns that his uncle had murdered his father and married his mother within a month after his father’s death. His immediate temptation is to kill his uncle, but the more he thinks about this, the more he lapses into a lassitude about his plans, continually forgetting about having formulated it, and at other times coming up with reasons why his uncle’s act might have been politically justified. What would the psychoanalysts say? Why, that I had just written a play about a hero whose behavior can be explained by his repressed Oedipal fantasies—exactly the same explanation that Jones fashions to explain the behavior of Shakespeare’s Hamlet, a character who does the opposite of the hero in my play. And here we have an excellent illustration of what psychoanalysts tend to do with any scenario. It is always reduced to the same equation no matter what the manifest scenario. Formulations that explain everything explain nothing. Just what scenario might it be that would, on Sir Karl Popper’s criterion of scientific legitimacy, count as falsifying psychoanalytic interpretation?

The above point was driven home for me when, years ago I was invited to the home of an analyst for a summer weekend. A sign above the front door of his cottage on Fire Island read “Oedipus Rex.” My host was a chess player, and during a match with him I had the occasion to remark that Dr. Reuben Fine, another psychoanalyst, had authored a paper on the Oedipal fantasies inherent in chess. My host scoffed at the very idea, since for him Oedipal fantasies cut across all kinds of behavior, so it was no news it should make a similar appearance in chess. If white plays P-K4, the player is unconsciously preoccupied with the father figure, with the intent of murdering him; if he plays P-Q4, he is preoccupied with the mother, possibly to sexually possess her after murdering the father figure; if he plays N-KB3 or N-QB3, he is intent on bypassing or repressing his unconscious preoccupation with Kings and Queens. All these moves are popular ones in chess because they are dictated by rules governing the opening game. That is, there are strategic reasons for the moves in question, and these have absolutely nothing to do with the unconscious psychology of players, unless we mean by this their unverbalized, albeit rational decision-making based upon certain rules of the game.

Jones goes on to develop his thesis of Hamlet driven by the incestuous idea of sexually possessing his mother. His explanation for Hamlet’s being able to kill Claudius at the end of the play bears scrutiny:

 

There are two moments in the play when he is nearest to murder, and it is noteworthy that in both the impulse has been dissociated from the unbearable idea of incest. The second is of course when he actually kills the King, when the Queen is already dead and lost to him for ever, so that his conscience is free of an ulterior motive for the murder (Jones, 1949, p. 100).

 

            Jones implies that the unconscious wishes responsible for Hamlet’s delay in killing his uncle Claudius no longer activate inaction after his mother Gertrude dies from poison. How is such an assumption derived, even from the psychoanalytic formulation? If the Oedipal conflict is the chief player in Hamlet’s unconscious, whence the deduction it is less instrumental because of the real demise of the mother figure? In other words, why should Gertrude’s death have any bearing at all on Hamlet’s weakened inhibitions to avenge his father? Jones here fudges deductions that reconcile Hamlet’s murder of Claudius with the hypothesized reasons for his being unable to do so—right up to the point he actually follows through with the deed.

In the play there was an actual attempt on Hamlet’s part to kill his uncle—thus refuting the psychoanalytic stress on unconsciously derived delay, although Jones fudges the point in a like-minded way. This is the scene in Gertrude’s chamber when Hamlet stabs an intruder hiding behind an arras:

 

How now, a rat? Dead for a ducat dead. Thou wretched, rash, intruding fool: farewell: I took thee for thy better (Italics mine—DAB)

 

          Polonius is, at the Danish court, an adviser who appears to be the closest to being a prime minister. There is no “better” above him as far as social station is concerned except royalty, like Hamlet, Claudius, and Gertrude. The implication is clear: Hamlet thought he was killing Claudius, mistaking Polonius for him. Jones’ spin on this, a convoluted explanation of why Hamlet’s Oedipal conflict prevented him from killing his uncle prior to his mother’s actual demise, is as follows:

…Hamlet did not have the king in his mind when he struck this blow…After all, he had just left the king engrossed in prayer, and the latter could hardly have rushed in front of him to the bedroom. The words that have given rise to the common misunderstanding (“I know not. Is it the king?”) are surely to be read as a response to his mother’s alarm, combined with a typically irrational “wish-fulfilment” that his task has by a lucky accident been accomplished. “Thou wretched, rash, intruding fool, farewell: (insert: for a moment) I took thee for the better” comes then when he realizes the impossibility of his previous thought (or wish). Soon after this the ghost appears, which would have been superfluous had Hamlet seriously intended to kill the king, and Hamlet admits his recalcitrance (Jones, 1949, p. 37).

This will never do. The appearance of the ghost (whom Gertrude, unlike her son, does not see) in no way underscores that he goads Hamlet on the supposition the latter has lost completely the intention to avenge him; he comes as a reminder to expedite the matter, since getting on with it should move ahead expeditiously, and give no sign of “blunted purpose.” The ghost announces his visitation is only to “whet,” not recreate, that purpose.

            Furthermore, both Hamlet and Polonius exit at the end of Act III, Scene iii, leaving the king in prayer. There is no indication of a specific passage of time after this that would make it implausible for Hamlet to assume it was Claudius who was hiding behind the arras. (And who else would one assume was thus situated in Gertrude’s bedchamber?) Hamlet arrives there after calling from within: “Mother, mother, mother!” and the interval of time between his entrance here and his exiting from the king’s presence is left unspecified. It could be minutes, hours, even days.

            Jones has it that Hamlet is passionate and decisive when it comes to most other matters, but dilatory when it concerns avenging his father’s death:

Hamlet is a man capable of very decisive action, with no compunction whatever about killing. This could be not only impulsive, as in the killing of Polonius, but deliberate, as in arranging for the death of Guildenstern and Rosenkrantz…He shows no trace of hesitation when he stabs the listener behind the curtain, leaps into the grave with Laertes or accepts his challenge to what he must know was a duel, or when he follows his father’s spirit on to the battlements, nor is there any lack of determination in his resolution to meet the ghost…On none of these occasions do we find any sign of that paralysis of doubt which has so frequently been imputed to him…the whole picture is not, as Goethe depicted, one of a gentle soul crushed beneath a colossal task, but one of a strong man tortured by some mysterious inhibition (Jones, 1949, pp. 37-39).

            Jones’ thesis then, is that Hamlet is a passionate and decisive person in every respect, although a hero overcome “by some mysterious inhibition” when it comes to avenging his father. Our only task now is to show why the psychoanalyst has not persuasively demonstrated any mysterious inhibition to execute revenge. In fact, there is no evidence in the text for any such thing. The idea that there is was, of course, first formulated by Coleridge. It predates psychoanalytic speculation about Hamlet although the latter appears to be a spin on the older formulation. In the Olivier film of the tragedy, the action is preceded by the actor’s voice announcing that “This is the story of a man who could not make up his mind.”

Hamlet is banished from Denmark by the king after the killing of Polonius. He is sent to England with Rosenkrantz and Guildenstern carrying royal letters to the English king requesting him to assassinate Hamlet. The secrecy of the mission is in part determined by Hamlet’s popularity with the populace, making it impolitic for Claudius to move against Hamlet on Danish soil. After Polonius’ death, Hamlet is obviously on the defensive, with little opportunity to exact his revenge on the king who is himself alerted to the danger to his person that Hamlet poses. One can, without bowdlerizing the text, imagine a palace guard around Claudius, a natural response of royalty to perceived danger. It is not long after his trip home that the fencing match with Laertes is arranged, and Hamlet on that very occasion exacts his revenge. We are thus faced with explaining the alleged “mysterious inhibition” of our hero prior to the death of Polonius.

Without belaboring themes of the play that have been reworked endlessly by other Shakespearean scholars, allow me to point out that an overriding one is the playwright’s preoccupation with appearance versus reality. That is, characters in the play frequently question what is real or unreal. The critic Maynard Mack in The World of Hamlet referenced what he calls the interrogative mood of the play. Hamlet’s killing Polonius, for example, is a crisis point in the action that puts the hero on the defensive because he misinterprets who lurks behind the arras. Hamlet’s very first speech in Act I, scene ii begins with a world play on the theme:

                                             Queen:   If it be,
Why seems it so particular with thee?
                                   Hamlet: Seems madam? Nay, it is. I know not ‘seems.’

The theme is taken up with other characters, and, indeed, is registered in the very atmosphere of the play. Especially noteworthy is Hamlet’s reflection on the reality of the ghost in his soliloquy in Act II, scene ii: “O, what a rogue and peasant slave am I!” This speech is important in its registering a legitimate doubt about the meaning of the ghost’s appearance. Hamlet detested his uncle Claudius even before the appearance of the ghost on the Elsinore ramparts: “So excellent a king, that was to this Hyperion to a satyr.” The ghost’s revelations that Claudius was both a murderer and an adulterer, resonate with Hamlet’s already established intimations: “O my prophetic soul!” meaning that he suspected something underhanded about his uncle, if not the actual sins the ghost enumerates.

            A psychoanalyst may conjecture that Hamlet’s doubts about the ghost is simply the temporizing effect introduced by the unconscious Oedipal conflict, but such a slant ignores the Elizabethan spin on matters theological, especially when it came to ghostly visitations. Hamlet’s doubts about the ghost were the entirely legitimate ones driven by the early modern thinking about the wiles of the Devil:

       …The spirit that I have seen
       May be a devil, and the devil hath power
             T’assume a pleasing shape, yea, and perhaps
       Out of my weakness and my melancholy,
 As he is very potent with such spirits,
                                        Abuses me to damn me.

Are these reservations about the ghost the transparent rationalizations for inaction the psychoanalysts would have us believe? Or are they the very real doubts Hamlet should harbor, given the thinking about the Devil that was dictated by the theology of an age?